Read the original article here.

---

Internet Trolls: Agents of Digital Manipulation and Control

In the vast landscape of the internet, interactions range from collaborative creation to constructive debate and casual socializing. However, lurking within digital spaces are individuals whose primary aim is not participation or contribution, but disruption, provocation, and manipulation. These are often referred to as "internet trolls." Understanding their nature, motivations, and tactics is crucial in the context of "Digital Manipulation: How They Use Data to Control You," as trolling represents a direct form of manipulation that impacts online environments and shapes public discourse.

This resource explores the phenomenon of internet trolling, analyzing how it serves as a mechanism of digital manipulation and contributes to controlling online narratives and individual experiences.

What is an Internet Troll?

Internet Troll: An individual who deliberately posts inflammatory, extraneous, or off-topic messages in an online community (such as a forum, chat room, blog comment section, or social media platform) with the primary intent of provoking readers into displaying emotional responses, disrupting normal on-topic discussion, or otherwise manipulating the online environment.

The term "troll" draws from folklore, where trolls are often depicted as monstrous or mischievous creatures who inhabit bridges or caves and cause trouble. In the digital realm, the "bridge" is the online platform, and the troll is the disruptor.

While casual provocation or expressing a controversial opinion might sometimes be mislabeled as trolling, the key distinction lies in the intent. A true internet troll's goal is not genuine debate or expression, but the act of disruption and the elicitation of negative emotional reactions.

Griefing: In online gaming and communities, "griefing" refers specifically to the act of intentionally harassing or annoying other players or users to spoil their experience. Trolling often overlaps with griefing, especially when the aim is purely to cause distress or frustration.

The Arsenal of Manipulation: Tactics Used by Trolls

Trolls employ a variety of tactics designed to manipulate interactions and outcomes online. These methods often exploit human psychology and the dynamics of online platforms.

1. Provocation and Disruption:

   • Posting Inflammatory Content: Introducing highly controversial or offensive topics into unrelated discussions.
   • Derailing Threads: Shifting conversations off-topic repeatedly or introducing irrelevant arguments to disrupt the flow.
   • Bad Faith Arguments: Pretending to engage in debate but using logical fallacies, straw man arguments, or misrepresenting others' positions solely to frustrate or anger.
   • Feigning Ignorance: Asking deliberately naive or simplistic questions on complex topics to waste others' time and patience.

2. Emotional Manipulation:

   • Targeting Vulnerabilities: Exploiting sensitive topics, personal information (if known or guessed), or group identities to trigger strong emotional responses like anger, sadness, or defensiveness.
   • Gaslighting: Denying or questioning a victim's experience or sanity to make them doubt themselves.
   • Emotional Outburst Baiting: Posting content designed to elicit angry or emotional replies, which the troll can then mock or use to further escalate the situation.

3. Spreading Misinformation and Disinformation:

   • While not all trolls spread outright falsehoods, many use misleading statements or outright lies to stir controversy or manipulate opinions. This blurs the lines between simple disruption and deliberate campaigns of deception.
   • Trolls can act as vectors for disinformation spread by more organized entities, amplifying false narratives through provocative posts designed to get shares and reactions.

Misinformation vs. Disinformation:

• Misinformation: False or inaccurate information, regardless of intent to deceive.
• Disinformation: False information deliberately created and spread with the intent to deceive, manipulate, or damage. Trolling can involve both, but when part of a calculated effort, it often involves disinformation.

4. Exploiting Anonymity and Identity:
   • Pseudonymity/Anonymity: Operating under fake names or without revealing their real identity provides a shield, enabling bolder and more aggressive behavior without fear of real-world consequences.
   • Sockpuppeting: Creating multiple fake accounts to amplify their own views, pretend to have support they don't, or harass individuals from multiple angles.

Sockpuppet: An online identity used for purposes of deception. This can involve creating multiple accounts to give the appearance of broad support for a view, to manipulate discussions, or to circumvent bans. A "meatpuppet" is a term sometimes used for a real person unknowingly or knowingly acting under the direction of another person's agenda.

The "Why": Motivations Behind Trolling

Understanding the motivations behind trolling helps reveal its connection to broader manipulative goals. Motivations are often complex and can range from individual psychological factors to organized political or financial objectives.

1. Psychological Factors:

   • Boredom/Entertainment: Some trolls engage in the activity simply for amusement or to pass the time, finding entertainment in causing chaos and eliciting reactions.
   • Attention Seeking: Trolling can be a way to gain attention, even negative attention, in online spaces where they might otherwise feel ignored.
   • Sadism: Research suggests a correlation between trolling behavior and traits from the "Dark Tetrad" of personality: narcissism, Machiavellianism, psychopathy, and sadism. Trolls may derive pleasure from the distress they cause others.
   • Sense of Power: Manipulating and controlling the emotions and reactions of others can provide a feeling of power or superiority.

2. Ideological or Political Agendas:

   • Trolling is frequently used to promote specific political ideologies, disrupt opposing viewpoints, spread propaganda, or silence activists and journalists.
   • This type of trolling is less about individual mischief and more about using manipulation as a tool for political influence and control over public opinion and discourse.

3. Organized and State-Sponsored Trolling:

   • Perhaps the most significant link to large-scale digital manipulation and control comes from organized trolling campaigns, sometimes state-sponsored. These operations employ groups of individuals (often referred to as "troll farms") whose job is to manipulate online conversation on a massive scale.
   • Motivations include:
     • Narrative Control: Pushing government propaganda or desired narratives and suppressing unfavorable information.
     • Political Destabilization: Exacerbating social divisions, spreading divisive content, and interfering in the political processes of other nations (e.g., spreading disinformation during elections).
     • Silencing Opposition: Harassing dissidents, journalists, and critics online to intimidate them into silence.
     • Economic Gain: While less common for pure trolling, related manipulative tactics (like spreading fake news for clicks) can be financially motivated.

Trolling as a Tool of Digital Control

Trolling is far more than just online annoyance; it is a potent tool for digital control, especially when executed systematically.

1. Controlling Narratives and Discourse:

   • By flooding comment sections, forums, and social media with inflammatory or irrelevant content, trolls can make it difficult for genuine discussion to occur.
   • Organized trolling can effectively "pollute" information spaces, drowning out factual content or marginalized voices with noise and provocation. This manipulates what information people see and what conversations they can have.

2. Silencing Dissent and Minoritized Voices:

   • Targeted harassment and aggressive trolling are frequently used to intimidate individuals or groups who hold dissenting opinions or belong to minority groups.
   • Facing a constant barrage of abuse can lead to self-censorship or withdrawal from online platforms, effectively silencing those targeted and limiting their ability to participate in public discourse.

3. Polarizing Communities:

   • Trolls excel at exploiting existing divisions and pushing people towards extreme viewpoints. By posting divisive content or attacking individuals based on their group identity, they can exacerbate conflict and make finding common ground more difficult. This is a direct form of manipulating social cohesion online.

4. Influencing Platform Dynamics:

   • The behavior of trolls (and the reactions they provoke) generates vast amounts of data – likes, shares, replies, reports, block lists.
   • Platform algorithms, often designed to promote engagement, can inadvertently amplify controversial or emotionally charged content, which includes troll activity. This creates a feedback loop where trolling behavior is rewarded with wider visibility, further manipulating the information ecosystem and user experience. Data about user reactions helps trolls refine their methods and helps platforms (often unintentionally) promote their content.

The Role of Data in Trolling (Implicit and Explicit)

While individual trolls may not use sophisticated data analytics, the phenomenon of trolling intersects with data use and manipulation in several ways:

1. Trolls as Data Collectors (Observational): Trolls observe what triggers reactions, what content gets amplified, and which users are susceptible to provocation. This observational data helps them refine their tactics and identify effective targets.
2. Targeting Based on Data: Organized trolling operations often use publicly available data, social media trends, and even scraped user data (though this is illegal) to identify vulnerable communities, key influencers to target, and topics ripe for exploitation.
3. Trolling Generates Data: Every troll interaction – the post, the replies, the shares, the time of day – is data. This data is used by platforms and, in some cases, by organized groups to analyze the effectiveness of their campaigns.
4. Algorithms Manipulated by Trolling Data: As mentioned, algorithms driven by engagement metrics can be manipulated by the high volume of reactions (both positive and negative) that trolling generates, leading to the promotion of manipulative content.

Responding to Trolling and Mitigating its Impact

Countering trolling requires a multi-faceted approach involving individuals, communities, and platform providers.

1. Individual Strategies:

   • Don't Feed the Troll: The most common advice. Responding emotionally is often exactly what the troll wants. Ignoring or blocking can be effective.
   • Identify the Troll: Recognize the tactics (lack of genuine interest in discussion, provocation, off-topic posts).
   • Report: Use platform reporting tools to alert moderators.
   • Limit Personal Information: Be mindful of what data you share online that could be used for targeted harassment.

2. Community Strategies:

   • Self-Moderation: Active community members can help identify and call out trolling behavior calmly and collectively.
   • Establish Norms: Clear community guidelines and expectations can make trolling less effective.
   • Support Targets: Offer support to individuals who are being targeted by trolls.

3. Platform Strategies:

   • Improved Moderation: Investing in human and AI moderation to identify and remove troll activity more effectively.
   • Algorithm Adjustment: Tweaking algorithms so they do not inadvertently amplify provocative or divisive content.
   • Identity Verification: While controversial for privacy reasons, some platforms explore stronger identity verification to reduce the shield of anonymity used by trolls.
   • Tools for Users: Providing robust tools for blocking, muting, and filtering content.

4. Enhancing Digital and Media Literacy:

   • Educating internet users about trolling tactics, common manipulation strategies, and how to identify misinformation is crucial. Understanding how they try to control you empowers you to resist.

Conclusion

Internet trolls are significant agents of digital manipulation. While some act out of individual malice or boredom, the phenomenon scales up dramatically when employed by organized groups for political, ideological, or financial gain. By using tactics of provocation, emotional exploitation, and the spread of misleading information, trolls aim to disrupt communication, silence opposition, and ultimately control online narratives and user behavior.

In the broader context of "Digital Manipulation: How They Use Data to Control You," trolling highlights how seemingly individual disruptive behavior contributes to a larger ecosystem of online control, exacerbated by platform dynamics and the flow of data. Recognizing the intent behind trolling and understanding its manipulative nature is the first step in mitigating its impact and fostering healthier, more open online environments.